Nowhere in dog ownership is confident advice so freely given as in a park. Much of it rests on a model of dog behaviour that was built on captive wolves in the middle of the last century, was popularised by television, and has since been abandoned by the researcher whose work started it.
It matters because the advice that follows from it is not merely useless. In fearful and guarding dogs it is actively dangerous.
Where it came from
The original idea came from studies of unrelated wolves housed together in captivity, which produced conflict and a rigid hierarchy. Later work on wild wolves found something different: family groups, where the so-called alphas are simply the parents. The researcher most associated with popularising the alpha model spent years afterwards trying to correct it.
Dogs, meanwhile, are not wolves. They diverged a very long time ago, they scavenge around humans rather than hunting cooperatively, and free-living dogs do not form rigid packs with a leader at the top.
The practical test: a theory that explains every behaviour explains none. If a dog jumping up, pulling, guarding a chew and barking at the door are all "dominance", the label is doing no work.
What the myths are, and what is actually going on
"He goes through the door first to assert himself." He goes first because the door leads to the walk and nobody has taught him to wait. Teaching a wait is useful; the reason given for it is nonsense.
"Never let a dog on the sofa or it will think it is in charge." Dogs like comfortable places. If you do not want a dog on the sofa, that is a house rule, trained like any other. It has no bearing on status.
"Eat before your dog." Dogs do not track the order of meals across a household.
"Alpha roll him to show who is boss." Pinning a dog on its back is confrontation. In a frightened dog it produces defensive aggression, and it teaches the dog that hands near it are a threat. This is one of the fastest routes to a bite in a family home.
"He knows he did wrong, look at his face." That expression is appeasement in response to your posture and tone, not guilt about a chewed shoe from three hours ago.
"He is being stubborn." Usually the dog does not understand the cue in that context, cannot do it at that distraction level, or has been paid too little for it. Stubbornness is a description of your frustration, not of the dog's motivation.
What replaced it
A duller and more useful model: behaviour that is reinforced increases, behaviour that is not decreases, and emotion drives most of the problems people call disobedience. Fear, frustration and arousal explain barking, lunging, guarding and biting far better than status does, and they point at treatments that work.
That is why current professional advice is built on managing the environment, changing the emotional response with distance and food, and teaching the dog what to do instead.
Why the old model persists
Because it is simple, it fits a story we like about leadership, and because suppression looks like success. A dog that has been punished for growling does stop growling. The owner sees a fixed problem; the dog still feels the same and has lost its warning.
It persists in marketing too. When you read balanced training, pressure and release, information, or all the tools in the toolbox, you are usually reading about aversives with a softer name.
How to judge advice
- Ask what happens when the dog gets it wrong. The answer reveals the method
- Be wary of anything framed as status, rank, pack or respect
- Watch the dogs in a class rather than listening to the instructor
- Ask whether they work with vets and refer when a medical cause is possible
- Trust your own discomfort. If a technique feels wrong to do to your dog, that is usually information
None of this means dogs need no rules. They need clear, consistent ones, taught kindly and applied by everyone, which is considerably more demanding than being the boss and considerably more effective.
General information for dog owners in Luxembourg, not veterinary or legal advice. For your own dog, ask your vet, a qualified behaviourist or your commune. How this journal is written and checked.
Away from your dog all day?
PAWLY provides individual dog walks, home visits and overnight care in your own home, across Luxembourg City. Same walker every time, written report after every visit.
Keep reading
All Training articles
The dog that barks and lunges on the lead
Every full episode sets the training back, which is why management comes before anything else.
Cues in a multilingual household
Three words for one behaviour is three times the work, and the dog is not being difficult.
Jumping up: fixing the greeting
You are not teaching the dog to stop jumping. You are teaching it what to do instead.
