The standard answer to a restless dog is a longer walk. Sometimes that is right. More often, especially in a flat on a wet January evening, what the dog is short of is something to think about, and that is available indoors, free, using food you were going to give anyway.
The principle behind all of it: a dog's brain is built for finding, solving and processing smell. An animal that gets its dinner in a bowl in nine seconds has had none of that.
Start with the food bowl
The simplest change with the biggest effect is to stop using it. The daily ration becomes the raw material for everything below, so none of this adds calories.
- Scatter feeding. Throw the kibble across a rug, across the balcony, or into a towel scrunched up on the floor. Nine seconds becomes fifteen minutes of nose work
- Snuffle mat. A commercial one, or a folded towel with food hidden in the layers
- Puzzle feeders and slow bowls, which also help dogs that eat too fast
- Stuffed rubber toys, filled with the dog's own food softened with a little water, frozen overnight. Twenty to forty minutes of licking, which is a calming activity in itself
- The muffin tin game. Food in the cups, tennis balls on top. Most dogs solve it in a week and enjoy it for years
- Cardboard. Food wrapped in a few layers of paper inside a box. Messy, free, and excellent, provided your dog does not eat cardboard
A dog that has worked twenty minutes for its breakfast sleeps through your morning calls. A dog that ate in nine seconds is looking for a job at ten o'clock.
Scent work, the highest-value activity
Hide a piece of food in the next room while the dog waits, then release it with a cue. Build up: more hiding places, higher, under things, in a different room. Then swap the food for a specific object, a cloth or a toy, and start rewarding the dog for finding that instead.
Fifteen minutes of searching does more to settle a dog than half an hour of walking, and it suits exactly the dogs that cannot have much physical exercise: recovering from surgery, arthritic, elderly, or too young for long walks.
Chewing and licking
Both lower arousal, which is why a dog often settles after a chew and why chewing appears when a dog is stressed. Provide legitimate outlets rather than treating chewing as a fault.
Choose chews that are appropriate to the dog's size and supervise them. Avoid anything you cannot dent with a thumbnail, antlers, hooves and hard nylon, which cause fractured teeth, and never give cooked bones. Rawhide is best avoided. A licking mat with something soft spread on it, frozen, is the cheapest calming tool there is.
Training as enrichment
Five minutes of teaching something new, twice a day, is genuinely tiring. It does not have to be useful: spin, touch a target with the nose, go to a mat, find the named toy, walk between your legs. Trick training has the same mental cost as serious work and considerably more appeal on a Sunday evening.
For dogs that need more, shaping games, where the dog works out what earns the reward through trial and error, are the most demanding mental activity most household dogs ever get.
The walk itself
Most of the enrichment available to a city dog is already on the route and gets rushed past. Give the dog permission to stop and sniff, on a longer line, for a decent part of the walk. A twenty-minute sniffing walk beats a forty-minute march for a dog that needs to settle afterwards.
Vary the route. The same loop every day is comfortable for you and monotonous for a nose, and a different street is a different newspaper.
What is not enrichment
Repetitive ball throwing. It raises arousal, builds a dog that is fitter and more demanding, and is hard on joints through repeated high-speed turns. Use a ball occasionally as a reward, not as a daily hour.
Laser pointers. A chase that never ends in a catch, which in some dogs produces genuine obsessive behaviour. Do not use them.
A television. Not company, not stimulation, though quiet background sound does usefully mask corridor noise in an apartment building.
Another dog, acquired to entertain the first one. It sometimes helps and it doubles everything else.
A realistic weekday
Breakfast scattered or in a puzzle feeder before you leave. A stuffed frozen toy given as you go out the door, which covers the first difficult twenty minutes. A midday walk with real sniffing time. Five minutes of training when you get home, before dinner, when the dog is most attentive. A chew in the evening while you eat.
None of that takes more than fifteen minutes of your day, and it replaces the restless hour that most owners try to solve with a longer walk in the dark.
Sleep, which is the other half
Adult dogs sleep a great deal, and dogs that are constantly stimulated are frequently under-rested rather than under-exercised. A dog that cannot settle in the evening may need less input, not more: a predictable routine, a quiet place away from the door, and periods during the day when nothing is happening at all.
Enrichment is not a competition to fill every hour. It is a way of making the hours the dog spends alone in a flat less empty, so the hours it spends with you can be calm.
General information for dog owners in Luxembourg, not veterinary or legal advice. For your own dog, ask your vet, a qualified behaviourist or your commune. How this journal is written and checked.
Away from your dog all day?
PAWLY provides individual dog walks, home visits and overnight care in your own home, across Luxembourg City. Same walker every time, written report after every visit.
Keep reading
All Behaviour articles
Adding a second dog: the honest version
Two dogs alone for eleven hours is two problems, not half of one.
Reading your dog: the signals people miss
A wagging tail is arousal, not consent. Here is the sequence dogs actually use before they growl.
Fireworks and noise phobia: preparing before December
The work that makes New Year survivable happens in September. On the night itself you are only managing.
