A dog does not know what it is called, which is precisely why the vocabulary matters. Every word in this subject is aimed at the humans, and each one carries a small set of instructions about what is expected of us.
Owner, guardian, parent
The legal word is owner, and it is accurate: in Luxembourg as elsewhere, a dog is property with obligations attached, which is why it is registered, taxed and insured, and why its behaviour is the owner's responsibility in law. The word is disliked because it sounds like a claim about status, but the obligations it carries are the serious ones.
Guardian is the reformist alternative, and it changes the emphasis usefully: something held in trust rather than possessed. It has no legal force here, and it describes an attitude rather than a duty.
Parent is the popular one, and it is the one that causes trouble, not because it is affectionate but because it imports a set of expectations from a different relationship. Children grow up, negotiate, leave and become independent. Dogs remain dependent for their whole lives and need structure rather than negotiation. A household that thinks in parental terms tends to over-supply affection and under-supply routine, which is the exact imbalance that produces most of the problems described on this site.
The vocabulary you choose sets what you think you owe. That is the whole reason to pick it deliberately.
The words that prescribe a response
Some terms are not descriptions at all. They are diagnoses with a treatment already attached.
Dominant says: assert yourself. It rests on a model of wolf behaviour that has been abandoned by the researchers who built it, and it turns a frightened or over-aroused dog into an opponent.
Stubborn says: insist harder. It describes the human's frustration, and it hides the four real possibilities: the cue is not learned in this context, the distraction is too high, the reward is too weak, or the dog is in pain.
Spiteful says: punish. It attributes a plan to an animal that does not form them, and it is most often applied to behaviour caused by distress, which punishment reliably worsens.
Aggressive, used as a character label rather than a description of an incident, says: this dog is like this. It turns a specific behaviour in a specific context, which is treatable, into an identity, which is not.
The softer distortions
Not all of it is harsh. Fur baby and its relatives are affectionate and mostly harmless, and they occasionally license things that are not: a dog carried everywhere rather than taught, a dog dressed for a photograph, a dog never allowed to be a dog.
Rescue is the other one worth watching. It is accurate and it can become the dog's entire identity, so that ordinary adolescent behaviour is read as trauma and a difficult week is explained by a past nobody actually knows. Plenty of rescue dogs are simply dogs.
And good boy, which is fine and universal, is worth occasionally translating into what the dog actually did, because "good" tells the animal nothing and the marker you use at the right moment tells it everything.
The habit that replaces all of it
Describe the behaviour before you name the character. Not "he is reactive", but: he barked and lunged when a dog appeared at fifteen metres, on the lead, on the narrow pavement, and he took food again once it had passed.
That sentence is longer and it contains a threshold, a context, a trigger and a recovery, which is four pieces of information a trainer or a vet can use. The label contains none.
It also has an effect on the person saying it. You cannot be angry at a sentence about distances. You can be angry at a dog that is being stubborn, which is why one vocabulary produces plans and the other produces arguments.
General information for dog owners in Luxembourg, not veterinary or legal advice. For your own dog, ask your vet, a qualified behaviourist or your commune. How this journal is written and checked.
Away from your dog all day?
PAWLY provides individual dog walks, home visits and overnight care in your own home, across Luxembourg City. Same walker every time, written report after every visit.
Keep reading
All Essays articles
The walk you do not feel like taking
The dog does not distinguish between the walks you enjoyed and the ones you endured.
Children, dogs and the supervision nobody does
The growl is not the beginning of the problem. It is the last polite stage of it.
What a walk actually costs
A price is meaningless without the group size and the travel time attached to it.
