Almost everyone starts by picturing a puppy. It is worth separating that picture from the practical question, which is what the first year looks like in a flat with two people who leave before eight and come back after six.
Both choices are legitimate. They are simply suited to different households, and the mismatch is what fills shelters with eighteen-month-old dogs.
What a puppy actually requires
- Somebody home. A young puppy cannot be left for a working day. The bladder sets the timetable, roughly one hour per month of age during the day, and the socialisation window will not wait for your annual leave
- Broken nights for several weeks
- A socialisation programme between eight and sixteen weeks: people, traffic, lifts, floors, noises, handling, being alone. Done badly or not at all, it produces the fearful adult that takes years of work
- House training, which in an apartment means a harness, a lift and a street door every time
- Adolescence, roughly eight to eighteen months, when the recall disappears and the skirting board does not survive
- Money: vaccinations, neutering discussion, replacing chewed items, classes, and grooming for the coats that need it
The upside is real too. You shape the dog's experience from the start, you know its history, and with the right household a well-raised puppy is a superb adult dog for a decade.
Be honest about one question: who is with the puppy between nine and five, Monday to Friday, for the first four months? If the answer is nobody, the answer to puppy or adult has been decided for you.
What an adult dog offers
Size, coat, energy level and temperament are known rather than predicted. Shelters and rescues have watched the dog daily and have no reason to flatter it. Many adults are house-trained, sleep through the night, and can be left for a reasonable working day from the first fortnight.
The trade-offs: you inherit whatever was or was not done in the first year, and some adults come with a specific problem, separation distress, a fear of men, reactivity on the lead, that needs work. The advantage is that you are told about it before you commit, which is rarely true of a puppy.
There is a settling period. Expect roughly three days of shock, three weeks of the dog testing and relaxing, and three months before you see the real animal.
The middle option nobody mentions
Dogs between five and eight years old are the hardest to place and frequently the best match for a professional household. They are past adolescence, their character is fully formed, they need moderate exercise, and most of them want a quiet routine and company rather than a project.
You get fewer years, which is the honest cost. You also skip the year that most owners find hardest.
Matching the dog to the actual week
Write down the real schedule rather than the intended one: departure times, return times, travel weeks, weekends away, who covers illness. Then ask what that week looks like from the dog's side.
Eleven hours alone is outside what a healthy adult dog manages comfortably, and far outside what a puppy can do at all. Either the schedule changes, or cover is arranged, or the dog is the wrong choice. Those are the three options, and hoping is not one of them.
Breed and size come after that, not before. A young working breed in a flat with an eleven-hour absence is the combination that produces the barking complaints, whatever the household intended.
Questions to ask, either way
For a puppy: can I see the mother with the litter, in the place they were raised; what health testing has been done; what socialisation have you started; will you take the dog back at any point in its life. Meeting in a car park, several breeds available, immediate availability and no questions about you are all reasons to walk away.
For an adult: what is known and what is guessed about the history; how does the dog behave when left alone, and for how long has that been tested; how is it with children, cats and other dogs, and in what circumstances was that assessed; has it ever bitten; what support is there after the adoption.
The Luxembourg specifics
Either way, the obligations are the same: identification and declaration to your commune, within four months of birth or within one month if the dog comes from abroad or from a previous owner; compulsory civil liability insurance; and the annual communal dog tax.
Check before you fall in love with a photograph whether the dog falls within the breeds classified as susceptible to being dangerous, because for those the owner's certificate and authorisation must be in place before you acquire the animal, and they limit who may walk it.
The decision, in one paragraph
If somebody is home for most of the first four months, if you want to shape the dog's early experience and you can absorb a year of adolescence, take the puppy and do it properly. If both adults work full days in the city, take a settled adult of four or more, from a rescue that will tell you the truth about it, and arrange the weekday cover before the dog arrives.
The second version is not a compromise. For a great many households in Luxembourg it produces the better dog and the better decade.
The PAWLY breed guide. 198 breeds described honestly, with history, temperament, health and what each is like in a Luxembourg flat. Browse the guide.
General information for dog owners in Luxembourg, not veterinary or legal advice. For your own dog, ask your vet, a qualified behaviourist or your commune. How this journal is written and checked.
Away from your dog all day?
PAWLY provides individual dog walks, home visits and overnight care in your own home, across Luxembourg City. Same walker every time, written report after every visit.
Keep reading
All Choosing care articles
Day care, a walker, a sitter or a kennel
The wrong format costs the same as the right one and produces a worse dog.
Choosing a dog trainer when the title means nothing
Ask what happens when the dog gets it wrong. The answer tells you the method.
What a new dog actually needs, and what to skip
Buy the bed and the food in advance. Buy the harness when you can measure the actual dog.
