The dog in the photograph is lying calmly under a café table in the sun. It is off lead on a beach, recalling perfectly at the moment the shutter closed. It has not barked at the courier, destroyed a skirting board or dragged anybody past a bin.
It exists, in the sense that the photograph is real. What does not exist is the animal implied by the photograph, which is a dog that behaves like that continuously, with no management, in a household identical to yours.
The invisible edit
Every image of a well-behaved dog is the survivor of a selection process. The forty seconds of settled lying down were preceded by an hour's walk and a chew, and the nine minutes of fidgeting before that were not filmed. The recall was called when the field was empty. The dog under the table is there on a mat that somebody trained for six weeks, or, just as often, it is eleven years old and no longer interested in getting up.
None of that is dishonest. It is what photographs are. The distortion appears when the viewer compares a highlight against their own continuous experience, which includes every bad Tuesday.
You are comparing somebody's best moment with your whole week. No animal survives that comparison, including theirs.
What comparison does to decisions
Guilt is the obvious cost and the less important one. The practical cost is that it produces the wrong interventions.
An owner who believes other people's dogs are naturally calm concludes that theirs is broken, and goes looking for a fix: the third training course, a stronger piece of equipment, a specialist for a problem that is a timetable, or a second dog to sort out the first. Meanwhile the ordinary explanation, that the animal is eleven hours alone, or two years old, or in pain, or simply a terrier, goes unexamined.
It also produces the opposite error: a household that sets a standard so high it stops noticing genuine progress. A dog that now barks for eight minutes instead of forty has improved enormously, and its owner is disappointed because a dog on the internet does not bark at all.
Management is not cheating
Behind most conspicuously well-behaved dogs is an arrangement rather than a transformation. The dog on the terrace has a mat and a chew. The dog that does not steal food lives in a house where nothing edible is left at nose height. The dog that is excellent with the postman is behind a gate at ten o'clock. The dog with a flawless recall is off lead only in three places its owner has chosen carefully.
Owners rarely mention the management because it is unglamorous and because they stopped noticing it years ago. The result is a public impression that these are simply better dogs, which is demoralising and false.
The only comparison worth making
Your dog three months ago. Can it be left twenty minutes longer than it could in spring. Is the lead loose for more of the walk than it used to be. Does it settle in the evening without being asked. Has the barking gone from forty minutes to eight.
That is a measurable standard, it accounts for your household and your dog's age and history, and it produces the opposite emotional result from the comparison with strangers: a sense that the work is doing something, which it usually is.
The dogs nobody photographs
Worth remembering that an enormous number of perfectly happy dogs would fail every test the internet applies. They pull a bit. They bark at the lift. They are reactive to spaniels for reasons nobody has established. They will not swim, will not fetch, cannot be trusted off lead and have never lain calmly under a café table in their lives.
They are also loved, walked, fed properly, taken to the vet and comfortable, which is the entire specification. The photograph was never the standard. It was only ever the best forty seconds of somebody else's afternoon.
General information for dog owners in Luxembourg, not veterinary or legal advice. For your own dog, ask your vet, a qualified behaviourist or your commune. How this journal is written and checked.
Away from your dog all day?
PAWLY provides individual dog walks, home visits and overnight care in your own home, across Luxembourg City. Same walker every time, written report after every visit.
Keep reading
All Essays articles
The words we use about dogs
You cannot be angry at a sentence about distances.
The walk you do not feel like taking
The dog does not distinguish between the walks you enjoyed and the ones you endured.
Children, dogs and the supervision nobody does
The growl is not the beginning of the problem. It is the last polite stage of it.
